bubuawards v.05 solution

Published 23 November 06 07:01 PM | adrian

Mr. Tahir and Mr. Norman have blogged about discrimination on this (or next?) year's bubuawards, self-tagged: "Indonesia's Most Prestigious Web Competition". While I know previous bubuawards reputation, the current limitation of web technology is amusing to discuss.

The amusement came from the Competition Requirements for Individual level, especially number 6 and 7 are a bit ambiguous.

One, they contain the same text to start: "The use of application programming languages and database..." This means that the rules will govern usage of programming in the competition. I've termed database together with the programming since you can't access the database without any programming.

Next is where the two rules forked. One stated that "such as ASP, MSSQL are not allowed" and the other "such as PHP, MySQL are allowed". "such as" indicates that there are more (other than the ones listed), but the differentiation isn't clear. What would .NET and Java qualify? Python? RoR? PostgreSQL? Perl scripts?

Word is, the organizer cannot provide platform availability for said technologies. 

AFAIK, every single web technology available now is trial-able. Take, for example, Microsoft Windows Server 2003 required to run ASP.NET applications. Microsoft have provided a trial version of it that runs for 180 days. Long enough to deploy and vote, IMO. If you're concerned about licensing, you can check the EULA for Windows Server 2003.

In the first paragraph of the said license, Microsoft have stated that you can use the evaluation version to demonstrate and evaluate. That is exactly what they're going to do. Demonstrate the submissions, and evaluate the designs. The second statement is about production/live operating environment. Since all of the submission would be mock-up version, this shouldn't count as a production environment.

To conclude, I think bubuawards organizer need to extend their web technology allowances (by reiterating through all of the options stated above), or lessen it altogether. Make it just a combination between XHTML, CSS, and JavaScript. Or they can split the competition between web developers (that deals with application logic) and web designers (that deals with user interface). This will create a better and fair competition.

Share this post: | | | |
Filed under:

Comments

# dondy said on November 23, 2006 07:55 PM:

Godong, good point. If they're reason is licensing stuff, you explain it well. However, dunno if the reason is something else

# Satya said on November 23, 2006 11:19 PM:

What else makes sense?

# norman said on November 24, 2006 09:12 AM:

Yup, Godong. Good details. I don't know why bubuawards folks don't think it that way... 180 days trial should do the job (if licensing is the problem).

http://www.wikimu.com/News/DisplayNews.aspx?id=362

# agung said on November 24, 2006 09:48 AM:

I think the problem is they do not have the hardware !

If they have, and also have a little time to read Windows Server 2003 EULA, the question will never arise. :-)

If the problem is providing hardware, they can contact server hardware from vendor like HP, Dell, IBM for this event ? Can you see the sponsorship and the judge ? :-)

There is only one word .... DISCRIMINATION !

# Agung Riyadi said on November 24, 2006 11:23 AM:

Menarik membaca komentar-komentar dari : Tahir Tahang [ V ] Norman Sasono [ V ] Adrian Godong [ V ] Agus

# Rahadian said on November 24, 2006 12:58 PM:

well, guys actually we gonna launch the student expression awards which will be specialized in using Microsoft Expression software...and we engage those all activity with seminar & workshop from campus to campus and build the Microsoft Expression Community www.cabeijo.com ( we just launch today-24 Nov- at Club Rasuna at 4 o'clock, i hope all u guys can be there, please contact devi at 70576600 for RSVP ) and dont forget, join the student expression awards ( www.bubuawards.com ) & Cabe ijo ( www.cabeijo.com ) Cheers !

# adrian said on November 28, 2006 03:17 PM:

Intinya bukan ada barang Microsoft apa ngga, tapi kesetaraan aturan yang jelas. Yang dirugikan di sini bukan cuma web developer ASP, tapi juga yang namanya ngga kesebut, macam Java, RoR, Perl, Python, XAML (UI), PostgreSQL, Oracle, etc...

Makanya, kalau memang tidak siap untuk mengakomodasi seluruh platform yang ada, mending dibatasi saja (HTML + XML only). Ini lebih fair dan lebih mencerminkan "Indonesia's Most Prestigious Web Competition". Ini kompetisi web, bukan cuma PHP-MySQL, orang Indonesia juga ga cuma pake PHP-MySQL.

Kecuali kalau alasannya memang panitia bubuawards menganggap orang Indonesia "cuma" bisa pake PHP-MySQL...